Rating of steering wheel manufacturers
In auto parts stores you can find components for cars of all brands. Most tips are produced for the aftermarket, but there are brands that supply their products for assembly line assembly. We selected for testing tie rod ends from companies with a good reputation that have been operating on the market for more than 20 years. The analysis was performed using instrumental methods. When compiling the review, the opinions of service station foremen, dealership representatives, and reviews from car owners were taken into account.
When analyzing manufacturers, the following factors were taken into account:
- Assortment – leading brands offer end caps for cars from Europe, Asia and America;
- Reputation - the best companies produce products that meet international and European standards for assembly line assembly parts;
- Materials used - the use of durable alloys, innovative copolymers improves technical characteristics and increases wear resistance;
- Market presence – availability of spare parts and availability of service centers contributes to increased trust in the brand;
- Security - branded packaging, several degrees of protection against counterfeiting allow you to buy an original part.
Not all manufacturers were able to meet the requirements of the expert group. Unstable quality, market shortages, weak assortment - such brands were excluded from our rating.
Working method
You need to do the following:
1. Hang up the car and remove the wheel, not forgetting to install a reliable safety stand.
2. Clean the parts with a wire brush and spray the joints with a penetrating fluid such as WD-40 or equivalent. These are mixtures of white spirit with anti-corrosion and lubricating additives.
3. Loosen the nut securing the pin and the locking connection of the toe adjustment unit. One turn is enough. It is better to go through the thread of the pin nut several times until it rotates freely.
4. Install the puller onto the ball joint. Pullers come in different designs; it is most convenient to use a device in the form of a wedge fork; a couple of strong blows to its end are enough. The screw puller does not always cope on its own; it needs help with a sharp blow of a hammer on the bipod of the steering knuckle.
5. In the absence of a puller, you can create tension in the connection using the same pry bar, and then apply sharp blows to the edge of the bipod. The finger will detach with a characteristic click. All that remains is to unscrew the threaded end of the rod and install a new one.
The disadvantage of such a simple replacement is the need to immediately carry out operations to adjust the wheel alignment angles, as they say, wheel alignment. We must remember that replacing the tip does not affect the camber in any way, only the toe-in of the wheels changes.
If you approach the work carefully, have a sufficiently large caliper or tape measure, and understand the principles of toe adjustment, then additional costs can be avoided.
To do this, you need to perform the following operations with the highest possible accuracy:
1. Before starting to loosen the nuts, make two marks. The first should be located exactly in the center of the circle of the back of the ball joint. There are usually ring stampings or rolling. Their center must be calculated, at least using a caliper. In the found center, it is advisable to make a small depression with a light blow of a sharp core. Carefully check to see if there is any slight shift of the mark from the center. Repeat the procedure on a new tip.
2. On the steering rod, from the inside of the threaded connection, apply an annular mark lying exactly in a plane perpendicular to the axis of the rod. Smooth and neat.
3. Using a caliper or tape measure, measure and record the distance between the applied marks.
After installing the new tip, rotate the adjusting connection to achieve the same result. Lock the threads.
Despite the possibility of preserving the previously existing toe angles in this way, it will still be safer and calmer to visit the stand. The toe-in angle is quite accessible for measuring in a garage yourself; you can find various techniques in numerous tips from home craftsmen for repairing their own cars.
The best manufacturers of tie rod ends
Experts recommend that car owners buy steering ends from a well-known company for one reason: the accuracy of control and the safety of the driver and his passengers depend on the quality of these chassis parts. The best brands offer to select parts according to the make of the car; they have an assortment of right and left steering tips, boots made of durable and elastic materials. Replacement of quality parts is carried out quickly, accurately, with a warranty period.
The VyborExperta.ru team tested 15 companies and recommends choosing one of the 8 brands presented in the review. Spare parts from these companies have an extended service life, cope well with high dynamic loads, and are always available in specialized auto stores.
Lemforder
The German concern was founded in 1937 and supplies chassis components for BMW, Mercedes-Benz, Man, Daf and Volkswagen conveyors. The parts meet the standards of automakers in terms of quality, geometry accuracy, and durability. The catalog contains products for cars, trucks and commercial vehicles. The engineers of the German company offer solutions that take into account the characteristics of the installation space and the materials used.
To expand the range, the company attracted well-known German and South Korean brands to cooperate: Ctr, Sachs, Knecht. These enterprises produce components on request from Lemforder in accordance with customer standards. Employees of the German corporation control the quality and technical parameters of the tips, which are packaged in boxes with their brand. This allows us to offer owners of budget cars spare parts that will last 100-150 thousand km.
Advantages:
- Good quality anthers;
- Accurate transmission of steering commands to the wheel;
- Low price;
- Resistance to high loads;
- Good protection against counterfeiting.
Flaws:
- The quality of the lubricant varies among different factories operating at Lemforder.
The company offers to use a regularly updated online catalog, which will help you choose a part taking into account the car make, year of manufacture, engine size and body type. Users can submit technical inquiries and receive detailed information from Lemforder about materials, design features of spare parts.
Delphi
The American concern unites enterprises operating in 33 countries. The catalog contains 16,000 items for passenger and commercial vehicles. In Europe alone, Delphi has 6,800 distributors, which makes it easy to select a spare part for any car. The brand offers products in 30 product groups; chassis parts are among the best in their price category.
To protect against counterfeiting, the company applies numbers from its catalogs to parts using high-quality stamping. The components are indicated with a batch number and a QR code; all information is duplicated on the original packaging and a bag made of dense, durable polyethylene. The reliability of Delphi undercarriage products is confirmed by laboratory tests. The average mileage with American brand tips was 150 thousand km.
Advantages:
- Good quality boots and cuffs;
- Exact size match to original products;
- High quality carving;
- Low price;
- Prevalence in the market.
Flaws:
- Insignificant amount of lubricant.
Moog
The American concern Moog is a supplier for Ford and GM assembly lines and covers 60% of the American secondary component market. Until 2001, the company focused only on the domestic needs of the United States, but for 20 years it has been producing parts for European cars. The main production facilities of the holding are located in the USA, which ensures high quality.
The range covers the needs of 95% of European car owners. Reviews about Moog tie rod ends are positive. Users note the high quality of the cuffs and metal, good corrosion resistance. In terms of technical characteristics, the parts comply with assembly line assembly standards, and the average service life exceeds 150 thousand km.
Advantages:
- Good protection against counterfeiting;
- Stable quality;
- Wide dealer network;
- High quality threaded connections.
Flaws:
- High price.
Qsten
The trademark belongs to the Japanese concern Sankei Industry, which is known for its “555” brand. The Qsten line is the premium series of this manufacturer. The components are designed for use in difficult road conditions and are designed for car owners who regularly drive not only in the city, but also off-road. The average mileage for steering tips is 50-55 thousand km.
The range is designed for the secondary market of European, Asian and American cars. Spare parts are produced taking into account the standards adopted by automakers. According to reviews from service station specialists, you can replace original parts with Qsten components without additional modifications. This saves time and ensures a high level of safety on the road.
Advantages:
- Good metal resistance to corrosion;
- The quality is not inferior to the original tips;
- Low price;
- Long-lasting anthers.
Flaws:
- Deficiency in online catalogs.
TRW
The German company Trw owns production facilities in Germany and Spain. The main activity is the production of components for the secondary car market. The catalog contains spare parts for the steering system and suspension of cars from Europe, South Korea, Japan and the United States.
According to reviews from car owners, the quality of TRW tips is inferior to original products. If conveyor assembly parts last 100-150 thousand km, then brand products last 75-80 thousand km. This is compensated by the price, which is 2-3 times lower than that of original spare parts. The manufacturer takes care of protection against counterfeiting; on the packaging you can find holograms and QR codes that confirm the authenticity of the products.
Advantages:
- High wear resistance;
- Withstand increased loads;
- Good quality copolymers;
- Sufficient lubrication;
- Minimum defect rate.
Flaws:
- Not the widest range.
N.K.
The brand belongs to the German concern SBS, which produces consumables for the budget segment. The products have European and international certificates according to the most stringent standards. The main production base is in Europe, and a small part of the capacity is located in Asia. The brand's spare parts are designed for the secondary automotive market.
The company is actively introducing innovative technologies that allow it to produce products of above-average quality. The manufacturer is characterized by a minimum percentage of defects; this was achieved by careful control of all stages of production. The catalog contains consumables for cars of all brands, including steering ends for VAZ and other Russian brands.
Advantages:
- Low price;
- Good branded packaging;
- Full compatibility with original spare parts;
- Long-lasting anthers.
Flaws:
- Manufacturer's warranty is no more than 3 years.
CTR
The South Korean manufacturer produces spare parts for assembly lines of KIA, Hyundai, Daewoo, GM and Ford. All Ctr products are certified according to international standards. The concern supplies more than 1,000 types of spare parts to Japanese automakers. The brand's products can often be found in original packaging from well-known brands at a higher price. The components produced for KIA are universal and suitable for Hyundai vehicles.
At Ctr enterprises, attention is paid to the quality of the polymer materials and alloys used. This makes consumables durable and resistant to high loads. The brand carefully monitors protection against counterfeiting: spare parts are supplied in branded boxes with holograms and QR codes.
Advantages:
- Dense and elastic anthers;
- Good thread quality;
- Average mileage 100 thousand km;
- Low price.
Flaws:
- There are many fakes on the market.
RTS
The Spanish company produces 16 million parts per year, delivering to the European, American and Asian markets. The components are certified according to international standards. For suspension, RTS factories produce a full range of products. High-quality alloys and elastomers are used in production.
The assortment includes individual parts and kits, the quality of which is not much inferior to assembly line spare parts. The average mileage is 80 thousand km, while the price differs from original components by 2-3 times. The dough company cooperates with another Spanish concern IRB, in whose packaging you can find RTS tips.
Advantages:
- Dense anthers;
- Reliable crimp rings;
- High wear resistance;
- Products for passenger cars and commercial vehicles.
Flaws:
- Poorly protected from counterfeiting.
Repair procedure
The replacement algorithm includes several points:
- Jack up one side, remove the wheel, turn the steering wheel so that the tip is in a position convenient for replacement.
- Spray the connections with penetrating liquid.
- Unscrew the fastening nut.
- Pull the tip out of the hole in the steering knuckle.
- Check the condition of the steering rods and replace them if necessary.
- Replace the part.
- Reassemble in reverse order, repeat operations for the other wheel.
Service technicians are interested in what measures can be taken to protect threaded connections from dirt and moisture. The main thing is to thoroughly lubricate the threads with graphite lubricant or lithol. Some additionally put a tube of a suitable size at the junction of the rod and the tip or use heat shrink.
After replacing the VAZ 2114, it is best to adjust the wheel alignment. There is a way to avoid this though.
When removing the old tip, count the number of turns, and then tighten the new one by the same number. Then, when driving at low speed, make sure that the car does not drift sideways when the steering wheel is straight.
How to choose a tie rod end
A good selection in auto stores and on the Internet makes you think about which brand of steering arms you should buy for your car. Original components are not always suitable for the price, but there are many brands in the catalogs offering parts for the secondary market that are not inferior to assembly line spare parts. To choose a tip that can last a long time, you need to learn to distinguish the original from the fake. It is recommended to order components only when using electronic catalogs that take into account the specifics of the vehicle make and model year.
The original or a fake
All companies presented in the rating have an impeccable reputation, but you can find negative reviews on the Internet. This is due to the installation of counterfeit products on the car. Counterfeits are sold in automotive markets at a lower price, which is especially noticeable when comparing products from American and German companies with products supplied from Southeast Asia.
Leading manufacturers protect their reputation. The same codes are applied to the parts and packaging, which coincide with the data from specialized catalogs. Additional protection - stickers with holograms and QR codes. The encoded data must match the information on the packaging. QR codes can be deciphered using applications developed by manufacturers and distributed via the Internet.
A counterfeit is always characterized by low quality printing: unclear inscriptions are applied to the packages, poor quality cardboard is used, and the corporate color scheme is not followed. It is not recommended to buy such spare parts; the maximum mileage for counterfeit spare parts is 10-15 thousand km. This does not justify the cost of components and repairs.
Selection by car brand
A difference in size of 1-2 mm can cause premature failure of the part, problematic installation, and low accuracy when transmitting steering commands. You need to choose tips taking into account the make of the car. This can be done using electronic catalogs, which are available to service departments and spare parts sellers. Leading manufacturers offer to use branded catalogs on specialized websites on the Internet.
In the electronic catalog, the user selects the language in which it is convenient to receive information, indicates the make, model, year of manufacture, engine size, body type. For each car we offer a part that fully matches the dimensions of the original spare part. This helps avoid mistakes, ensure simple repairs and ensure precise vehicle control in all conditions.
Lada 2114 16V “Super vAto” › Logbook › About steering tips…
In general, this part usually lasts quite a long time.
There are quite a lot of reviews on the Internet that the steering wheels, even on our basins, were not changed until the mileage was as much as 100k. But for some reason I have no luck with them... Still at 20 tk. something knocked on the left. It rattled on small bumps. I made a mistake on the rail. Yes, and 2 different masters at different services pulled the steering rods and issued a verdict - “The rack is rattling. Big backlash. You can tighten it up, but it won't last long. We'll have to change it soon." I tightened it so that the steering wheel began to bite. The knocking seems to have gotten smaller. But a week later it began to rattle again as before. I was already thinking that I need to put aside money for a rail from the SS-20. This seems to be the only rack on the VAZ that inspires at least some confidence. But because The car was still under warranty, so I decided to try going to the “officials” - maybe they could get me a replacement under warranty? I went to Kan-auto. The master pulled the rods - “Yes, everything is fine with the rack, it’s even slightly overtightened. » We lifted the car onto the lift. And immediately they found the cause of the knocking - the left tip was playing in the vertical plane with an amplitude of almost a centimeter. Unfortunately, the tips, as well as the entire suspension, only have a one-year warranty. But because I was still going to switch from the prioro suspension to the 08th, but I wasn’t particularly upset - I’m going to go to the alignment anyway, the ends on the VAZ are not that expensive and I’ll install normal ones right away so that they will last for a long time. In the end I chose Lemforder. I ordered them at Exist for 300 rubles each. They are really neatly made. Each is packaged in a separate bag and in a separate box. The boot has a plastic protective cap on top. Instead of locking nuts with a cotter pin, the kit comes with self-locking nuts - everything is “foreign-made” =)
The only thing I didn’t like was the place of production - Serbia. Will this affect German quality?
This happened last summer. I changed the suspension and drove happy. But already in the middle of winter, something began to rattle again on small hummocks. “Well, that’s it - I think - now the rail is definitely covered.” Somehow I didn’t even think about sinning with “German” tips. I tightened the rack again almost all the way. I went for a ride. But the knock hasn't gone away. Really again? I only drove 8 thousand after the replacement. I went to the service center. That's right - this time the right tip is ejected. Here's Lemfoerder for you...
This time I took the usual VIS in the BBC. They don't look like anything at all. Looks like they were made in some kind of basement. There aren't even nuts and cotter pins included.
I hope quality doesn't depend on appearance. This was exactly the case with Lemforder. Time and kilometers will tell...
Source
Which manufacturer's steering ends are better?
For car enthusiasts who are interested in the question of which steering ends are best, the VyborExperta.ru team recommends products from companies that have contracts with car assembly line enterprises. These factories produce spare parts that meet the requirements of automobile concerns. The accuracy of geometric dimensions and the use of materials with detailed characteristics allow the parts to serve no less than original spare parts.
The products of the companies included in our TOP 8 differ in price, technical support and availability. For this reason, our experts recommend the following brands, taking into account the needs of car owners:
- Lemforder is a good choice for German cars;
- Moog - tips with increased safety margin;
- Qsten – spare parts for high-quality budget repairs;
- CTR – components for South Korean cars;
- NK – parts from Germany for the Russian automotive industry.
Products from the best manufacturers ensure safety on the road and help reduce operating costs.
Consequences of a malfunction
The steering end screws onto the long steering rack arm. This achieves a movable connection between the rack and the steering knuckle, but at the same time it is quite rigid. Long trips with a faulty tip will lead to serious problems with steering and more. Tires are most often affected.
During long trips with faulty joints, wheel alignment is disrupted. This causes increased wear of the rubber. But this is far from the only consequence of problems with the tip. In fact, this hinge should protect the steering rack from impacts and shocks. If there is a malfunction, this function is lost; if you continue to drive further, the risk of damaging the rack becomes quite large.
Who is last?
You can't pronounce the full name of these products at the counter. “External steering linkage extreme rod ends for classic Lada cars - what is it like? In general, today we are checking the “outermost helmsmen”. Or, even more briefly, we find out: who is the last?
As always, there are two main types of purchased products: “ours” and “not ours”. “Ours” are also divided into two subgroups: according to the materials used and methods of heat treatment of the ball pin. Thus, the product from ZAO NPO Belmag, shown in photo 1, has (be patient!) a ball pin made of 12ХН steel using the cold heading method, followed by nitrocarburization of the spherical surface of the head to a depth of 0.1–0.3 mm and current hardening high frequency to hardness HRC 55–61. Many manufacturers purchase such fingers from Belebeyevsky Plant Avtokomplekt LLC. Products from VAZinterservice were manufactured in a similar way (photo 3). The rest of the domestic “steering” ones contain ball pins made of steel 40ХН with subsequent machining and volumetric hardening to a hardness of approximately HRC 30. This group includes the Miass “Kedr” (photo 2), two products from the Vladimir “Progress” (photos 4 and 5) , an unnamed tip (photo 6), sold to us as “Belebeevsky” and turned out to be also from Vladimir, as well as “second-hand” from the Moscow market (photo 7). The quartet of “foreigners” is represented by the British Lockheed (photo 8), the Swiss Federal Mogul (photo 9), the Spanish IRB (photo 10) and the Italian OKAP (photo 11).
Among the design features of the presented “steering units” we note the following. All “Russians”, as well as the Italian OKAP, have a spring inside that presses the spherical head of the ball pin to the surface of the polymer insert. The other end of the spring rests against a support washer rolled into the hinge body - this compensates for the wear of the rubbing pair. The rest of the products do not have a spring - the tension ensures that the support washer is pressed against the polymer insert during rolling.
The tests were carried out according to a program close to the certification one. Each “brand” was represented by two products. The main “legislators” are the design documentation of VAZ and RD 37.001.613–97 “Ball joints of vehicles. " The results are shown in the table. As an optional check, rubber covers for the “steers” were tested.
The following happened. When checking the longitudinal and transverse swing angles, almost no complaints arose - only one of the “Italians” was “outside the game.” During the “strength exercises” of squeezing and tearing fingers out of the body, the Moscow homemade products, which were unexpectedly accompanied by the “Spaniards,” completely failed. And the “geometry lesson” determined that the “Swiss” and “Spaniards” had heads that were too small by our standards.
The size of the heads is only one component of the longevity of the steering wheel. Here, not only the diameter of the spherical surface plays a role, but also the cleanliness of its processing, the quality of the liner material, the hardness of the surface (in case of partial penetration of dirt), as well as the design of the protective covers and their wear resistance. It turned out that the working surfaces of all the “foreigners” and our “Cedar” were processed better than others, while the rest were limited to rough grinding.
There is no unambiguous interpretation of the results regarding hardness. At first glance, all foreign tips failed, except Lockheed, as well as domestic products from VAZinterservice with nitrocarburization, but “ours” were justified! Experts explained that in February 2000, AvtoVAZ JSC allowed the Belebey enterprise to carry out hardening to a hardness of HRC 39.1 - while the surface hardness of such fingers still remains higher than those subjected to volumetric hardening. Well, that means we're all right.
Examination
Yes, in order to accurately determine that the limit switches are the culprit for the uncharacteristic behavior of the car, they should be checked. How to do it? Let's get a look.
- Examine the condition of the node visually. To do this, turn the steering wheel all the way to the right. This will allow you to look at the left tip. To visually inspect the right unit, you need to turn the steering wheel all the way to the left.
- Look at the rubber boot. It fits onto the tip. The presence of signs of rupture or cracks clearly indicates that the steering element needs to be replaced.
- If you do not do this, dirt will penetrate through the gaps and cracks in the boot, which will ultimately lead to very rapid wear of the part and can harm other components of your car.
- You can also lift the car with a jack by hanging the wheel in the air. Grasp the tip with your hands and shake it.
- If there is play, then the replacement will have to be performed on both sides simultaneously.
The defect is obvious
Experts strongly do not recommend changing tips individually. Even if the second element is intact, it is better to perform a double replacement.
Examination
Yes, in order to accurately determine that the limit switches are the culprit for the uncharacteristic behavior of the car, they should be checked. How to do it? Let's get a look.
- Examine the condition of the node visually. To do this, turn the steering wheel all the way to the right. This will allow you to look at the left tip. To visually inspect the right unit, you need to turn the steering wheel all the way to the left.
- Look at the rubber boot. It fits onto the tip. The presence of signs of rupture or cracks clearly indicates that the steering element needs to be replaced.
- If you do not do this, dirt will penetrate through the gaps and cracks in the boot, which will ultimately lead to very rapid wear of the part and can harm other components of your car.
- You can also lift the car with a jack by hanging the wheel in the air. Grasp the tip with your hands and shake it.
- If there is play, then the replacement will have to be performed on both sides simultaneously.
The defect is obvious
Experts strongly do not recommend changing tips individually. Even if the second element is intact, it is better to perform a double replacement.